Tone for declining a co-author request in a manuscript?
I am finishing my doctoral dissertation in public health and a former lab partner just emailed me asking to be added as a co-author on my final journal submission. I need to politely decline because I want to maintain sole authorship, but I am worried about burning bridges in such a small academic department. How do I phrase this rejection in a professional manner without sounding dismissive of their earlier informal help?
1 Answer
Use a courteous, appreciative tone that acknowledges the person’s contribution, cites the authorship criteria you’re following, and clearly states that the manuscript will remain single‑author. This approach shows respect, provides a factual basis, and avoids any implication of personal dismissal. Start by thanking them for the specific help they gave—whether it was troubleshooting a protocol, offering informal feedback, or sharing a reagent—and then explain that the journal’s authorship guidelines (and the standards of your department) require substantial intellectual contributions such as study design, data analysis, or manuscript drafting for co‑authorship. State that, because the work you are submitting was conceived, executed, and written primarily by you, you must retain sole authorship. A concise example might read: “I’m grateful for the assistance you provided with the field surveys last spring; however, the manuscript reflects the research questions, analysis, and writing that I developed independently, so I will be submitting it as a single‑author paper in line with the journal’s authorship policy.” The single most helpful piece of advice is to frame your decision around an external, objective standard—like the journal’s authorship policy—rather than personal preference. By grounding the refusal in widely accepted criteria, you reduce the chance that the colleague interprets it as a slight and you preserve the professional relationship. For instance, a student who helped collect data but did not contribute to the study design or manuscript drafting could be thanked for the data collection while being told that those contributions alone do not meet the co‑authorship threshold. This clear, policy‑based explanation signals fairness and keeps the focus on scholarly standards, making it easier for both parties to move forward without tension. End the note by expressing willingness to acknowledge their help in the acknowledgments and by offering to stay in touch about future collaborations.
Similar questions
Have a similar question?
Ask the community →