🎓 EduPathHub

How do I respond to a reviewer demanding new data for a major revision?

editing-proofreading ▲ 1 5 views 2026-10-08

Reviewer two wants me to add a second site and a full year of observations. That is six months of fieldwork and a second ethics amendment. Reviewer one was positive. Is this a reasonable request or a sign I should withdraw?

0 Answers

No answers yet.

Reviewed by the EduPath Hub editorial team under our editorial policy. See our methodology.

Similar questions

How do I get feedback when no doctoral writing support exists at my institution?My professor provided incomplete feedback on my research paper. What should I do?Can I have someone edit my essay for grammar?My professor's feedback on my research paper is vague. How can I effectively revise it?

Have a similar question?

Ask the community →
Share this question: Share Reddit